Conference Paper
Machine Learning

Secure, privacy-preserving and federated machine learning in medical imaging

Georgios Kaissis(Imperial College London), Marcus R. Makowski(Technical University of Munich), Daniel Rückert(Imperial College London), Rickmer Braren(Technical University of Munich)
June 8, 2020Nature Machine Intelligence1,388 citations

1.4k

Citations

50

Influential Citations

Nature Machine Intelligence

Venue

2020

Year

Abstract

The broad application of artificial intelligence techniques in medicine is currently hindered by limited dataset availability for algorithm training and validation, due to the absence of standardized electronic medical records, and strict legal and ethical requirements to protect patient privacy. In medical imaging, harmonized data exchange formats such as Digital Imaging and Communication in Medicine and electronic data storage are the standard, partially addressing the first issue, but the requirements for privacy preservation are equally strict. To prevent patient privacy compromise while promoting scientific research on large datasets that aims to improve patient care, the implementation of technical solutions to simultaneously address the demands for data protection and utilization is mandatory. Here we present an overview of current and next-generation methods for federated, secure and privacy-preserving artificial intelligence with a focus on medical imaging applications, alongside potential attack vectors and future prospects in medical imaging and beyond. Medical imaging data is often subject to privacy and intellectual property restrictions. AI techniques can help out by offering tools like federated learning to bridge the gap between personal data protection and data utilisation for research and clinical routine, but these tools need to be secure.

Analysis

Why This Paper Matters

This paper addresses a critical bottleneck in medical AI: the scarcity of large, shareable datasets due to privacy regulations and ethical constraints. By reviewing federated learning and related privacy-preserving techniques, it provides a roadmap for training robust models without centralizing sensitive patient data. The paper's focus on medical imaging is timely, as imaging data is abundant but highly sensitive, and the harmonized DICOM standard already facilitates data exchange, making federated approaches particularly feasible.

The paper also emphasizes the need for security, not just privacy, by discussing attack vectors such as model inversion and poisoning. This dual focus is essential for real-world deployment, as naive federated learning can still leak information. The paper thus serves as a foundational reference for researchers and practitioners seeking to implement privacy-preserving AI in healthcare.

Technical Contributions

The paper's key contributions include:

  • A structured overview of federated learning architectures (e.g., client-server, decentralized) and their applicability to medical imaging.
  • Discussion of complementary privacy techniques such as differential privacy, secure multi-party computation, and homomorphic encryption, and how they can be combined with federated learning.
  • An analysis of potential attack vectors, including gradient leakage, membership inference, and model poisoning, and possible defenses.
  • Consideration of practical challenges like communication overhead, heterogeneity of data, and regulatory compliance.
  • Future outlook on next-generation methods, including personalized federated learning and blockchain-based approaches.

Results

As a review paper, it does not present new experimental results. Instead, it synthesizes existing literature and identifies best practices. The paper's impact is reflected in its high citation count (1388), indicating its influence on subsequent research in privacy-preserving medical AI. It does not provide quantitative comparisons of methods, but rather qualitative guidance on selecting appropriate techniques based on use cases.

Significance

The paper has significantly shaped the discourse on privacy-preserving AI in medical imaging. It has informed the design of numerous subsequent studies that apply federated learning to tasks like tumor segmentation and disease classification. By highlighting both privacy and security, it encourages the development of robust systems that can withstand adversarial attacks. The principles discussed extend beyond medical imaging to other domains with sensitive data, such as finance and genomics. This work contributes to the broader goal of enabling collaborative AI while respecting data sovereignty and patient confidentiality.