Back to Community
Chatgpt vs Claude vs Perplexity (for Marketing)
rocxky November 24, 2025
101 likes
Honestly , I was fully expecting ChatGPT to win.
I've been using it since GPT-3 dropped, and honestly thought this would just confirm what everyone already believes.
I was wrong.
I ran 5 tests: idea generation, market research, sales copy, visual content, and competitive research.
Paid for all three subscriptions ($60 total). Scored them blind before revealing which AI gave which response.
ChatGPT scored 4.5/10 on idea generation.
It gave me the same generic "start a blog or dropshipping business" advice from 2015.
Meanwhile, Claude gave me a complete execution framework with startup costs and a 5-day action plan.
For sales copy? ChatGPT was forgettable. Claude understood persuasion architecture - the kind of copy that actually converts.
The only place ChatGPT won was visual content (native DALL-E), and even then, Perplexity tied it.
Perplexity absolutely crushed research with real-time citations. 9.5/10.
But for strategy and copywriting? Claude won 3 out of 5 challenges with 8.5+ scores.
I'm not saying ditch ChatGPT entirely - the voice mode is still unmatched.
But if you're paying $20/month for creative or strategic work, you're probably paying for hype, not performance.
Full breakdown with scoring methodology in the video.
Would genuinely love to see if anyone gets different results.
Drop your scores below if you test this yourself.
Comments
More Community
View allThe golden age is over
I really think the golden age of consumer and prosumer access to LLMs is done. I have subs to Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. I am running the same chat (analyse and comment on a text conversation) with all 4 of them. 3 weeks ago, this was 100% Claude territory, and it was superb. Now it is lazy, makes mistakes, and just doesn’t really engage. This is absolutely measurable. I even saw an article on [ijustvibecodedthis.com](http://ijustvibecodedthis.com/) (the big free ai newsletter) - responses used to be in-depth and pick up all kinds of things i missed, now i get half-hearted paragraphs, and active disengagement (“ok, it looks like you dont need anything from me”) ChatGPT is absurd. It will only speak to me in lists and bullets, and will go over the top about everything (“what an incredible insight, you are crushing it!”). Gemini is… the village idiot and is now 50% hallucinations. Perplexity refuses to give me the kind of insights i look for. I think we are done. I think that if you want quality, you pay enterprise prices. And it may be about compute, but it may also be about too much power for the peasants.
C
Complete-Sea6655 137
Come on perplexity...
I've been using perplexity mcp via API to fact check output form Claude desktop, only using it once in awhile credit just ran out today after a few months of usage. We used to be able to top up any amount, come on man why you gotta be greedy I don't need $50.
H
HzRyan 105
I have been put into debt by Perplexity
Last I checked (two days ago) I had \~500 Computer credits remaining. I haven't used Computer in two days. Today I see that Perplexity has charged me for around 3,000 credits without any warning. Would love to know why I have been gutted of my few remaining credits. Regardless, I will be filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy
A
azeddev 93
Perplexity has become garbage
Have gotten and used pro for the past three months, but it's gotten absolutely unusable at this point. Previously it was actually useable for lots of stuff like deep research, even a little bit coding since it connected nicely to GitHub. Now it's just pure garbage. Gets stuck on a coding task that would require changing literally two lines of code and freezes. Not to mention they switched Kimi 2.5 for nemotron, which is less capable to say the least. Claude is so much better for literally anything. On god they've ruined what would have been the most useful AI product on the entire market.
A
allezjames 125
Computer rolling out for Pro users as "pay-to-play"
Give us free daily credits Aravind, cmon...
C
Chasmchas 118
perplexity replaced moonshot kimi Ai with Nvidia Nemotronmodel
I don't know much about this model so i asked it to perplexity sonnet and nemotoron itself and both saying it's a downgrade model from kimi to this model. what your thoughts guys, is there any speciality in this new model which other lacks, share me your thoughts
L
Late-Examination3377 213